This is a great article on the Silent Treatment and Borderline Personality Disorder

5 posts / 0 new
Last post
#1 Nov 29 - 5PM
gettinbetter
gettinbetter's picture

This is a great article on the Silent Treatment and Borderline Personality Disorder

I have recently come to the conclusion that my Narc is a male Borderline and this article confirmed it. This is him to a tee! He is definitely the Cassanova type who is alway the victim.

Borderline Personality - The Quiet Acting In Borderline and The Silent Treatment - Nons
Borderline Personality Disorder (BPD) has two distinct dysfunctional relational styles. The "acting-in" style of many with BPD is known as the quiet borderline. The result of relational style of the quiet borderline often culminates in the silent treatment. The best known and recognized style of many with BPD is that of the "acting out" or raging borderline.

A key thing to note about these two primary relational styles of presentation within Borderline Personality Disorder is that both the quiet borderline and the raging borderline are often experiencing similar aspects of borderline pathology. The only difference between these two relational styles or groups is the method of manifestation of the borderline traits. One style acts in the pathology of BPD and the other acts it out. Both are experiencing the same underlying issues and have the same abandonment issues coupled with emotional dysregulation and an inability to cope with that dysregulation, to soothe it, and to take and hold personal responsibility for it.

There is much more written about the raging borderline relational style. However for both the raging acting out borderline and the quiet borderline - the acting in borderline at the centre of their rage is feeling/perceiving or fearing abandonment, feeling/perceiving invalidation. The acting out borderline whose needs are thwarted or who doesn't get his or her own way aggressively and often abusively yells, name calls, and screams about how they feel and what they feel others have done to cause how they feel. While the quiet borderline, the acting in borderline, will give you an aloof stone-cold silence when he or she is enraged.

The stone-cold silence of the quite acting in borderline is often also used whenever a non borderline really wants and needs to talk, set boundaries, get some input about what is really going on in a relationship from the borderline. This silence is an abdication of personal responsibility.

Borderlines, whether they are quiet acting in borderline or raging acting out borderlines, often experience what they are actually feeling and/or doing as coming from the other person in an interaction because they essentially are living through other in the absence of a known self.

The "acting-in" borderline, when he or she experiences rage, is frustrated, experiences the thwarting of his or her needs, or simply doesn't get what he or she wants, more often than not passively-aggressively uses the silent treatment as a means of defense through avoidance and also as a form of punishment.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Nov 29 - 5PM
Susan32
Susan32's picture

It's big among cerebrals too...

The former professor was more of a psychopath/cerebral Narc than a Casanova, and he definitely used the silent treatment. During my junior year, when he'd go quiet on me, I'd comment aloud "That's one guilty-sounding silence." Then he'd glare, since I was onto him like a mountain lion when it's against a lone coyote. I'd tell him he came across as guilty and he'd get visibly discomfited. I was trying to address issues, set boundaries (he was complaining about me dating on class time to his students, despite the fact he and I weren't dating, and we weren't even casual sex buddies) Too bad I was empathetic enough to be on his case about it.
Nov 29 - 5PM
gettinbetter
gettinbetter's picture

This is my Narc to a tee!

He has given me the silent treatment for a couple of months usually when I ask something of him or questioned him regarding the relationship. I also read that male borderlines are typically the cassonova type which he definitely is.
Nov 29 - 8PM (Reply to #2)
blueeyes
blueeyes's picture

SOI

I got the silent treatment many of times. Days long and we lived together. He wouldn't even answer a simple question like "Did the baby eat?" Uhm, I kinda need to know. lol. Interesting because I must read about this when I am ready. I bet the silence feels like rejection? I know it did for me :( No woman should ever be ignored.
Nov 29 - 8PM (Reply to #3)
Susan32
Susan32's picture

Being ignored by one's teacher

It's painful, isn't it? I got the silent treatment from a teacher. It's painful from a lover, a spouse, the father of one's children. I'd ask questions... and they wouldn't even be personal... they'd be about philosophy, my writing, normal academic stuff... and I was basically ignored and rejected. He'd especially ignore me if I was happy and/or enjoying academic success. It was 4 years of the silent treatment, evasiveness, changing the subject. Imagine this in a classroom setting where classes are supposed to be discussions instead of lectures. I couldn't even have an intellectual, non-romantic, impersonal conversation with him.