Cold empathy--Sam Vaknin

13 posts / 0 new
Last post
#1 Sep 2 - 8PM
Anonymous (not verified)
Anonymous's picture

Cold empathy--Sam Vaknin

This is such a good little video. Challenges the idea that narcs have no empathy. Vaknin claims they have self serving or 'cold empathy'. Whether cold empathy can really be deemed empathy at all is a question, but it's an interesting concept.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y1MkZb9FWos

Sep 2 - 10PM
Hunter
Hunter's picture

If only it was as easy as

If only it was as easy as taking out the batteries and put the robot to rest ! Love Sam!
Sep 2 - 8PM
ruby01 (not verified)
Anonymous's picture

I'm

not so sure about this one. I don't really buy it. I think he's just talking to hear himself. Usually he makes sense. This just seems implausible.
Sep 2 - 8PM (Reply to #2)
enpsychopedia r... (not verified)
Anonymous's picture

I had the same initial

I had the same initial reaction, but watch it again. It makes sense in my situation. My narc was crazily intuitive, sensitive to the slightest change in my moods, etc... But it didn't last. As soon as the courtship phase had played out, 18 months later, he dropped me like a hot rock. No feeling, no empathy at that point. Had we gotten married, as planned, I would have had to put up with a total nightmare of a complete lack of care and concern, or a man who pretended to care at the best of times. My point is, they DO 'care'--but only for a short time. Our instincts about that weren't mistaken. They simply cease to have any feeling for us and it can happen overnight. That's a horrible thought, but can be understood, given time. The reason I think this should be highlighted, is because I don't think it does any woman any good to be told that it was always an act, right from the beginning. For me, that thought is sanity shattering. Others may not experience that idea the same way.
Sep 2 - 9PM (Reply to #11)
freaked
freaked's picture

imho, a Narc does not possess

imho, a Narc does not possess the requisite chemicals in his blood for real Care/Love/Attachment. after nearly 6 months of researching about NPD/Psychopathy this is my conclusion. Empathy by its intrinsic nature is Warm. When empathy is served cold, it is called Manipulation. Happy weekend to all my friends here... i am sending out warm regards to one and all. Cheers to our collective healing. We all just have to learn to be like a lotus flower. “As a lotus flower is born in water, grows in water and rises out of water to stand above it unsoiled, so I, born in the world, raised in the world having overcome the world, live unsoiled by the world”: Buddha quotes (Hindu Prince Gautama Siddharta, the founder of Buddhism, 563-483 B.C.)
Sep 2 - 9PM (Reply to #10)
onwithmylife
onwithmylife's picture

my take

I think they care about us to the extent of what is in it, for THEM..but no real empathy it is all an act.....
Sep 2 - 8PM (Reply to #3)
ruby01 (not verified)
Anonymous's picture

Okay,

I think it is nothing but a game from the get go. Once they think they "have" you, GAME OVER. You are no longer a challenge, you are worthless, and in their eyes pathetic for allowing them to gain your trust. They might have an adrenaline rush at first because you are new and that's exciting, but care about you= NO WAY
Sep 2 - 10PM (Reply to #8)
CaminoReal
CaminoReal's picture

Ruby01--a question

I absolutely agree that this is a game the entire time and that they lose interest once they have us, but I just CAN'T understand how and why he stays with gf#1 for over 2 years. He has "had" her the whole time and he is still with her, so to speak. There is no future for them as she is already married and does not intend on leaving her husband. She is an authority figure for him as is her husband. The three of them go out every weekend and they carry on in front of him. It makes me sick.
Sep 2 - 10PM (Reply to #9)
ruby01 (not verified)
Anonymous's picture

CaminoReal

There is no future for them as she is already married and does not intend on leaving her husband. I think you just answered your own question. As long as this woman remains married she is not a threat to him losing his "uniqueness" A future is the last thing he would want with a woman.
Sep 2 - 9PM (Reply to #4)
enpsychopedia r... (not verified)
Anonymous's picture

I agree. It's a game. They

I agree. It's a game. They use cold empathy to play the game. I think the problem is with the term, "empathy". It doesn't denote real care and concern, for them. It just means they can imagine how you feel. They CAN put themselves in your shoes. If they couldn't do this, they wouldn't be able to be so perfectly cruel. Have you ever known anyone who could cut you to the quick, like they can? It's because they can imagine what it's like to be you. This is also why 'mean girls' are so mean. Women, being more empathetic are capable of great feats of compassion because they can imagine so well, how it feels to be you. They can also use that empathy to torture you. They know just what to say to hurt you, cut you right to the bone with their tongues. Ruby, Yes, once they have you the challenge is off, the ego is satiated and needs to find other sources. The conquest is part of the ego challenge. Sick huh?
Sep 2 - 9PM (Reply to #7)
Susan32
Susan32's picture

What scared the ex-P...

After the final D&D, I told the ex-Psych prof that I cared about him, that I empathized with him... then he told me his whole pity routine WAS AN ACT. The thought that I could put myself in HIS shoes made him extremely uncomfortable. He could tell what I was feeling... that's why the final D&D was so painful... he knew what would hurt me&he did. On the same token, he preyed on me because I'm empathetic... and what scared him was that as an empath, I KNEW what could hurt him. When I gleefully recounted how the senior skit ridiculed him... I KNEW it would cause narcissistic injury. He knew the empathy from me could give him endless quantities of narcissistic supply... but it could also give him the most cutting, painful narcissistic injuries. My empathy was a double-edged sword. My empathy, for him, was like morphine. Morphine is addictive&dulling... I'd constantly praise&listen to him... in the wrong quantities, morphine is DEADLY. Morphine is used to ease pain. I think the ex-P was PROFOUNDLY afraid that I'd treat him the same way he treated me. There were some points during the final D&D I'd tell him that his opinions were simply HIS, and the "walls" between us existed only in his head. There were times I'd basically tell him he was fantasizing... that he was talking about a theoretical teacher&student (he'd talk about himself in the third person,as "the teacher")... NOT US. The ex-P showed COLD empathy. He knew how I was feeling. But on the same token, I had empathy for him.
Sep 2 - 9PM (Reply to #5)
ruby01 (not verified)
Anonymous's picture

Remember though,

In the beginning you told them what upsets you. They did things that upset you. You let them know. They kept that info, in their memory bank, and bring it back out in the future, because they know from past experience that it will upset you.
Sep 2 - 9PM (Reply to #6)
mparamedic
mparamedic's picture

Exactly ruby01!

They CANNOT empathize or feel end of story! They hurt you not because they can feel but because they learn how to hurt you from YOU! They coerce you by acting like caring, loving souls only to get you to bear all about your past especially the really hurtful stuff. Once they know about your past hurts and what hurts you they use it against you because they already know the result. I noticed with my N that showing real true caring was not his motivation. "I need to help out my dad he's sick" translate into: I'm sneaking off to a party without you and using my dad's fabricated illness as my excuse. They only pretend to care to manipulate and satisfy whatever needs they have. They are predators and we are the prey. They know exactly what they're doing.