Must We Forgive?

20 posts / 0 new
Last post
#1 Nov 7 - 1AM
Anonymous (not verified)
Anonymous's picture

Must We Forgive?

excerpts
From the political to the personal, Americans are caught in an orgy of forgiveness. Failure to pardon, we're constantly admonished, will blight our lives. Now a psychotherapist counters that popular claim. You can refuse to absolve your lover, spouse, parent, sibling or friend, she declares, and still be emotionally healthy.

Flip to any television station these days and chances are we'll be witness to some dramatic episode of forgiveness. We see a mother and daughter estranged for years kiss and make up, a long-feuding couple holding hands and renewing vows, scandal-plagued politicians asking for absolution and granting it to their accusers. Tears flow, hugs proliferate, and the inevitable psychological experts solemnly intone that traditional psychotherapy has neglected this essential element of cure and that studies show that forgiving alleviates depression and enhances self-esteem.

What's wrong with this picture? The capacity to forgive is an essential part of an examined life. However, enshrining universal forgiveness as a panacea, a requirement or the only moral choice, is rigid, simplistic and even pernicious. Yet that is exactly what we have done. Today we demonize not forgiving as much as we idealize forgiving.

Failure to forgive, therapists caution, is to "doom yourself to be a victim for the rest of your life," while clergy warn that it inexorably leads to a "recycling of evil."

Yet some of the most admirable, sane and emotionally healthy people that I know have not forgiven on occasion. Not forgiving needs to be reconceived. It is not an avoidance of forgiveness or a retreat into paranoia, but a legitimate action in itself, with its own progression, motivation and justification. There are many circumstances in which it is the proper and most emotionally authentic course of action.

I have found that there are three types of healthy unforgivers. For moral unforgivers, refusing means telling the truth, asserting fundamental rights and opposing injustice. Psychologically detached unforgivers accept the painful reality that they cannot experience the positive internal connection with a betrayer--usually a parent--which forgiving would require. Reformed forgivers have faced conflicts between feelings, religious principles, ethics or social responsibilities, and reject the conventional attitudes they once accepted. None of these three types is vindictive or against forgiveness in principle; they share the capacity to forgive but do not exercise it indiscriminately.

MORAL UNFORGIVERS
"In my family, the very act of unforgiveness is an extortion of my soul," declares Sandy Katz, a psychotherapist. "It endorses what they did, which was to deny the truth and pressure me to sacrifice myself. For me not to forgive my brother at my parents' behest is my self-affirmation."

Sandy's parents had looked the other way when her violent bully of an older brother thrust a screwdriver up her rectum--even when he set her on fire. "Afterward they didn't leave tools or matches lying around, but they never acknowledged what he did to me. He continued to behave this way and they continued to insist that I submit; my mother would say, 'He's just trying to get close to you because he doesn't know how to be friends.' She'd confuse me by saying it was all out of love, and I had no recourse."

Parents define a child's world; there is no escape. Unsure of their own reality, children who have no validation and no protection become prisoners mentally as well as physically. Not forgiving is a recourse they can create only as independent adults, a way to free themselves from years of being coerced to agree that hate is really love.

Under the pressure of promoting family harmony, parents who need to deny one child's viciousness and their own negligence often try to force the victimized child to be "mature" and "rise above it." These more intact, "good" siblings continue to make the same demands of themselves. Their willingness to accept bad treatment, to feel they deserve it, or to define it out of existence then extends beyond their families and damages their later lives. Even those in less extreme circumstances tend to absorb parental values as an unexamined template for their own responses, making it difficult for them to distinguish what they truly feel from what has been imposed upon them.

Ten years ago, at age 35, Sandy finally defied her parents by refusing her brother's phone calls. "I started getting guilt-inducing messages from them saying that I was abandoning him and destroying the family. They became increasingly angry and accusatory, haranguing me to forgive and forget without admitting there was anything to forgive and forget. I wrote him a note detailing what he had done and said I wouldn't speak to him until he was willing to acknowledge it. He sent me back a letter taking the moral high ground: that he was just as hurt as I, that all children fight--as if these were normal childhood squabbles--and that he was willing to let bygones be bygones. Why couldn't I?"

Sandy hasn't attended a family function with her brother since she received that letter. "I've taken a strong position that he's out of my life, even though my parents still try to bully me into capitulating. I know it's difficult for them to have two separate sets of holidays, but I forbid them to talk to me about it because their Pollyanna attitude enrages me."

The moral unforgiver makes a distinction between the extreme circumstances where a relationship must be severed and other, more commonplace, injuries. "It's not so much what my brother did as a child, but what he continues to be as a man that I find unacceptable," Sandy explained. "He never changed, never grew, and just found new ways to feel entitled. It would only be right to forgive what he did as a child--it would be legitimate and healthy for everybody. But it would be wrong not to hold him responsible for being an undeveloped person now; I would be colluding in creating a false reality, which was what allowed me to be violated in the first place."

Contrary to the conventional wisdom, refusing to forgive or have further contact with an unrepentant, abusive relative is therapeutic. "My lack of forgiveness has not impeded my development or my relationships at all; in fact, it's cured me," she said. "Before I took a stand I was always depressed and acceding to others' needs, always confused about my rights and about what was real." It is commonly believed that forgiving promotes mental health and alleviates depression. But doing the opposite can express a person's very right to live.

Responsible unforgivers are never antiforgiveness; Sandy regularly forgives outside her family, even when the offender fails to apologize. "In a good relationship--not a perfect relationship--it's different; how bad are the screwups? If the person is still loving enough it comes naturally." By recognizing the distinction between actions worthy and unworthy of tolerance, and upholding her own moral point of view, a child triumphs over the masochistic role her family assigned her. Her insistence on truth and justice, which lead her to refuse to forgive, is the foundation of her sense of self. Says Sandy of her decision: "I've never had a moment's regret."

Proponents of universal forgiveness refuse to recognize that moral unforgivers exist. They find it inconceivable that unforgiving victims of injustice could be outraged but not obsessed by their injuries, that they could even sympathize or retain conditional connections with those they refuse to pardon.

What about Sandy's relationship to her parents, who at very least share responsibility for her childhood torment? She has not entirely severed her tie to them, though she holds them culpable. "I need some sense of family, as long as they accept my terms," she explains. "And with this huge exception, they have made genuine efforts in my behalf in recent years." Her attitude toward her parents is one of conditional unforgiveness.
~~~~~

Partial nonforgiveness requires a person to bear alone the burden of intense ambivalence and continuing grief. The illusion of family harmony is lost forever, but it is replaced with something limited, painful and real.

DETACHED UNFORGIVERS
Anybody who struggles with intimate betrayal must reengage with the experience, actively choosing to think and to feel what was once unbearable. But understanding need not lead to forgiveness. Indeed, it is a major accomplishment for some men and women to temper their hatred and tolerate their indifference. For the sake of their own emotional survival, they can do no more.

Disengaging from a fatally flawed parent or intimate, sometimes seems to come naturally, without anguish. Biochemist Annie Travers remembers never feeling anything but contempt for her father. "He was a selfish brute who considered his children his property. Once when I was a teenager, he said, 'I can do anything I want with you'--and he would have if my uncle hadn't threatened to call the police." Annie's uncle, a blind biologist who lived with the family, was her protector, mentor and soulmate. "He taught me how to think," she said.

Annie discussed what must have been a miserable situation with scientific detachment, and not a hint of recrimination. Throughout our interview, she referred to her father as "this guy," and seemed surprised when I asked what qualities she had inherited from him. "I'm my uncle's daughter," she said. Many children who had a poisonous parent identify someone else as their "real" parent.

Under the right circumstances, a traumatic past can be left behind without being consciously mourned. Living with a beloved, admirable uncle who shared and validated her feelings -- "I always knew we would be better off without my father and my uncle agreed with me," Annie said -- made her solution possible.

Still, no daughter is born despising her father; what became of her original love? "You have deep feelings, but they get lost," Annie admitted. "What love there was initially got strangled." As Annie matured, her fear and hatred evolved into indifference, and though she still speaks of her father with distaste, she is not bitter. "People are much too willing to blame others. Since I moved out 30 years ago, my life has been what I make of it--I'm responsible." A self-reliant attitude, the opposite of vengefulness, circumscribes the influence of a bad father.

Annie was away on a fellowship when her father died, and she had no qualms about not coming back for the funeral; in their last conversation he had berated her for not going to medical school. Annie is the first to acknowledge that her father had a negative impact on her life--"It took me a long time to feel men could be trusted," she said but she claims never to have been disturbed by her unwillingness to reconcile with her father. "I never felt the slightest need to do it."

Though friends and therapists have repeatedly warned her that her unforgiving attitude would eventually be her downfall, she isn't afraid they're right. "People try to convince me that because I didn't make peace with him I'd suffer for it down the line; they feel that there hasn't been closure. I think it's more about them and their own fathers. I'm fine. It hasn't been a trauma for me." For others to find Annie wanting because of what she has not done is an imposition of alien values. Annie is a woman at peace, at a price that does not seem excessive.
~~~~~~~

In the conventional view, the decision to forgive must not be based on whether the perpetrator deserves it; only then can the independent will of the victim be guaranteed. In fact, refusing to forgive a heartless mother or other betrayer expresses a person's right to his or her own feelings. Recognizing that you are under no obligation to profess love you do not feel is a hard-won freedom.

REFORMED FORGIVERS
We tend to think of forgiveness as the best, healthiest way to resolve an intimate injury, and of learning to forgive as one of life's greatest lessons. Sometimes the opposite is true. Learning not to forgive, after a life in which forgiveness has been compulsive, imposed or unconsidered, is an impressive achievement.

Daily life provides many circumstances where offensive and unchangeable behavior should not be excused and where forgiving is confused with submerging normal reactions to mistreatment. Yet even when the culprit is a peer and not a parent, and the injury is mundane, it can take years for a person to stop extending second chances.

Rita Bergman reversed her lifelong tendency to do what she was told when she turned 75. "As I've grown older I've begun to think more about what I need. Screw it, I don't have to forgive anymore," she exclaimed. The object of Rita's new found insight was an old friend who had become so obnoxious and critical that she was offending everyone she knew. "I felt terribly sorry for her. She hasn't been the same person since she lost her husband and son a few years ago, and she's all alone."

Repeated infuriating lunches, in which every aspect of her appearance was scrutinized and found wanting, made Rita vow to sever the tie, but she always ended up reconsidering for old times' sake. Only after Rita's closest friend refused to see her if this woman accompanied them did Rita realize enough was enough, stopped making the dates she had come to dread, and ended the relationship.

As with more serious injustices, understanding the source of someone's inexcusable behavior--even feeling sympathy for her plight--does not justify endless exposure to it; there is a fine line between compassion and compliance. "I don't believe in carrying grudges at this point in my life," Rita said, "but how long could I continue to ignore my own feelings? I was always very timid and never opened my mouth, but now that has changed." Rita's refusal to overlook her unfortunate friend's hostility any longer is an act of self-respect that took a lifetime to attain.

Forgiving without reconciling is acceptable; why not reconciling without forgiving? People often wound one another in the name of truth; a person has a right to employ judicial dishonesty to protect him- or herself against being wounded by others.

~~~~~~~~~

Forgiveness and unforgiveness are not polar opposites but points on a continuum. The same internal processes can lead to emotionally authentic resolutions in either direction. Anyone who has gone through the profound and punishing process of conscious forgiving or not forgiving emerges more self-aware, more related to others, and less burdened by the past.

When it is genuine, forgiveness is a capacity not a compulsion; this is why the same person can grant it or withhold it, depending on the circumstances. The ability to discriminate signifies maturity and freedom.

Madame de Stael was wrong. Understanding need not lead to forgiveness -- but it can lead to wisdom.

Adapted from Forgiving & Not Forgiving: A New Approach to Resolving Intimate Betrayal by Jeanne Safer, Ph.D. (Avon Books, August 1999).

Apr 29 - 8AM
neveragain5
neveragain5's picture

He asked me to forgive him a

He asked me to forgive him a lot, but never owned up to the behavior. Always an excuse for everything. His "apologies" just pissed me off more. At this point, I'm not willing to forgive because I know that he is doing it and will continue to do it with others. This to me, is unforgivable.
Apr 29 - 8AM
aceonelady
aceonelady's picture

forgive.....and forget

I am now pretty sure i can only forgive him if i could forget him....But i am sure that won't happen...i can give my pain and the craving i still feel for him a place i sincerely hope so,but i cannot forget him....i am in pain,sadness 24/7 ,i am on therapy for 2 years already,meds....but no i can't stop thinking about him....even some food reminds me of him....but he is NC and me too...the day i forgetbhim is the day i forgive him...

Aceonelady

Apr 29 - 7AM
woundedsoul36
woundedsoul36's picture

To forgive or not to

To forgive or not to forgive?? To each his/her own. I don't think it's wrong NOT to forgive or TO forgive. We are all different people, we all have varying degrees of suffering and pain we have been subjected to...people heal themselves differently. I'm just the type of person that feels forgiveness FOR ME is an important step to move on , let go, and be spiritually free from him.
Apr 29 - 6AM
narcnarcwhosthere (not verified)
Anonymous's picture

serial forgiveness

i think serial forgiveness has diluted what forgiveness should be all about......i don't think forgiveness should be dished up like dinner mints..... and even God doesn't forgive those who do not REPENT and SEEK forgiveness.... since Narcs and Psychopaths are NEVER sincere...it would be impossible for them to offer up the SINCERE APOLOGY...and REPENT....so they would never qualify for forgivness...at least in my book....... i love that line Barbara.......you cannot forgive an ONGOING CRIME........
Apr 29 - 7AM (Reply to #16)
Barbara (not verified)
Anonymous's picture

ongoing crime

yes - they don't repent - so how can we 'forgive' - they don't care... http://narcissists-suck.blogspot.com/2008/02/testing-for-repentance.html from: www.perfectapology.com A proper apology should always include the following: - a detailed account of the situation - acknowledgment of the hurt or damage done - taking responsibility for the situation - recognition of your role in the event - a statement of regret - asking for forgiveness - a promise that it won't happen again - a form of restitution whenever possible Now let's take a closer look at each of these ingredients and learn how to say I'm sorry in the most effective way. By giving a detailed account of the offence, you are making sure that both you and the other person are talking about the same thing. It also legitimizes the feelings of the recipient by having the person who caused the offence recount the situation. Keep in mind that you should be as specific as possible and your apology should be focused on the particular event(s). For example, if you missed an important date, don't apologize for your general absentmindedness but instead for missing that specific date. Next, by acknowledging the hurt or damage done, you are validating their feelings and the recipient begins to sense that you understand the situation. This is important to rebuilding your relationship because it legitimizes their reaction, even if others in the same situation may have reacted differently. Taking responsibility and recognizing your role in the situation without offering excuses is important to letting them know that you understand that the event and your actions did cause them harm. Don't try to defend yourself or justify the situation or your actions. The apology is all about THEM and how they feel. It doesn't matter if the actions were intentional or not, the end result is the same and that is what needs to be focused on when learning how to say I'm sorry. Including a statement of regret such as I "apologize" or "I'm sorry" along with a promise that it won't happen again are important to rebuilding the relationship and are key ingredients to any apology. After all, there is no value in apologizing for something that you will do again and again. Finally, asking for forgiveness at the end of the apology gives the "power" back to the recipient. It tells them, that you have done all that you can do by apologizing and providing whatever form of restitution you can. do any of us HONESTLY think our pathological could do any of this? I don't. ~~~~~~~~~ Moving Forward: Coaching for Victims Pathologicals Feelings buried alive never die. - Alice Miller
Apr 28 - 8PM
Introspection
Introspection's picture

Forgive....

I have forgiven even though he has not apologized...I'm at that point. I still have my moments but I needed to forgive to reach the point of indifference. This response could have been very different a couple of years ago when I was still suffering from severe depression...
Apr 28 - 7PM
woundedsoul36
woundedsoul36's picture

I can forgive. That's the

I can forgive. That's the best part of having a conscience, being human, and being normal. I'm not there yet, but I strive to be able to do so...because when I can, then I know I will be free: mind, body and spirit.
Apr 28 - 10PM (Reply to #13)
Barbara (not verified)
Anonymous's picture

forgive?

I forgive myself for sure. but them? No. They have never owned, apologized - so it's an Ongoing Crime. No forgiveness. In my religion, the abuser must ASK the abused for forgiveness at least 3 times. The abused can refuse to forgive. But - if the abuser never even asks! well - why bother. It's an outstanding crime that I see no reason to forgive for ANY reason. ~~~~~~~~~ Moving Forward: Coaching for Victims Pathologicals Feelings buried alive never die. - Alice Miller
Apr 28 - 7PM
sassyredhead
sassyredhead's picture

I have given up...

I have given up forgiving people who don't apologize or who apologize and then don't change the behavior. This includes my malignant narcissist step father, my narcissist porn addicted abusive husband and a few evil coworkers who would rather knife me in the back than be honest with me. I have also forsaken the golden rule in favor of the silver rule - treat others the way you want to be treated unless they betray you. Then treat them exactly the way they treat you. My tolerance for bull has decreased to the point where I don't tolerate crap from anyone and I am not afraid to tell them where they can stick it. Oh, in case you can't tell, I also have a problem with some residual anger lately over the way my step father and husband treat me... LOL! ;)
Mar 16 - 11AM
narcnarcwhosthere (not verified)
Anonymous's picture

forgive?....never..

no way...never.....
Mar 15 - 9PM
Barbara (not verified)
Anonymous's picture

Must We Forgive?

READ TOP POST ~~~~~~~~~ The world is a dangerous place, not only because of those who do evil, but because of those who look on and do nothing. - Albert Einstein Visit My Info. Website for Abuse Victims
Nov 8 - 9AM
AnotherPath
AnotherPath's picture

NO............no I won't

NO............no I won't forgive. And I won't stay angry because it doesn't serve me.

Ending the dance

Nov 8 - 4AM
tasha
tasha's picture

....

I thought so having christian influence in my life. But while I've been going to group, I've changed my opinion. Maybe letting go is a better way and making peace with it
Nov 8 - 4AM (Reply to #7)
Barbara (not verified)
Anonymous's picture

A Minister on Forgiveness

http://www.luke173ministries.org/templates/System/details.asp?id=39548&PID=466805 http://www.luke173ministries.org/templates/System/details.asp?id=39548&PID=466808 http://www.luke173ministries.org/templates/System/details.asp?id=39548&PID=466810 ~~~~~~~~~~~~ My Abuse Information Site Online Coaching & Help
Nov 7 - 2PM
Warrior1
Warrior1's picture

On forgiveness

I find that the smartest thing you can do is forgive someone if they are truly repentant, understand what the problem is and do everything in their power to change the situation/themselves. If none of this exists, I think it's fine to say, "The Hell with you. I'm thinking about my own needs now" and to completely cut the toxic person out of your life. I haven't spoken to my dad in many months. He's always been a lousy dad and I think a big reason why I've had troubled relationships with men almost my entire life. After a good chunk of my life has been spent trying to break through to him about my own needs, I finally said, "Enough is enough. All you do is make me feel terrible. I am not going to put myself in the position of becoming upset because of what you cannot give to me." Since I have stopped speaking to him -- essentially not forgiving him -- I have been the most happy I have ever been. It is only when I began to focus on myself and my own needs and not expect anyone else to fulfill them did I find true happiness! It's LIBERATING not to forgive!
Nov 7 - 10AM
cynthia (not verified)
Anonymous's picture

forgiveness

I will never forgive, I also wont carry around deep hatred in my heart for him, I just wont feel anything for him, he is dead to me, thats fine he can be dead but I will never forgive him for trying to destroy my life. I cant forgive him because that would mean giving him another excuse for his acts of crime towards me there are no excuses for what he did, they still know right from wrong, if he didnt that would be a different story.
Nov 7 - 7AM
4joys4
4joys4's picture

I'd like to "forgive"

I'd like to "forgive" whether he deeply means his apology or not. What I mean is this.. I move forward. I leave the situation in the dust but take along the lessons I've learned. I do not treat him as I did in the past but am neutral. Not really forgiveness but a sense of moving forward where his actions and words are neutralized. I think the word forgiveness is the problem. "To give as you gave before". No. I can't. But I have to heal as well.
Nov 8 - 6AM (Reply to #2)
Empathy
Empathy's picture

huh.. forgive??????????

WTF????? why the hell should we forgive??.. they dont even think or know they have done anything wrong??? I GAVE I GAVE I GAVE... I got f in nothing in return ... NEVER FORGIVE..or FORGET the BAD things and how evil they are. we must move on and live our best life...and that does not include forgiving them. If we lose our anger ... we lose the fight. just my opinion. I WILL Survive.
Apr 28 - 4PM (Reply to #3)
Barbara (not verified)
Anonymous's picture

Must We Forgive?

READ WHOLE THREAD ~~~~~~~~~ Moving Forward: Coaching for Victims Pathologicals Feelings buried alive never die. - Alice Miller